Michael Josephson Commentary
Josephson Institute  >  Commentary  >  Trust Is More Important Than Truth 641.4

Trust Is More Important Than Truth 641.4

A study titled “Parenting by Lying” reveals that most parents lie to their children, even though they tell their kids lying is wrong. The parents surveyed said they didn’t feel guilty because their lies were intended to accomplish legitimate parental goals such as getting a child to stop crying or protecting him or her from feeling bad or sad.

 


Reviewing the wide range of casual or careless lies told by parents to change behavior or manipulate emotions supports the observation that “the road to Hell is often paved with good intentions.”

Although honesty is an important virtue, I’m not a truth-telling fanatic. Truth can sometimes be sacrificed for another ethical value, and it’s sometimes okay to praise a present you dislike or choose kindness over candor.

My bedrock premise is that trust is more important than truth.

Playing with the truth is like playing with fire. It’s sometimes justified, but it’s unfailingly precarious. Lies are almost always bad because they almost always destroy trust.

Thus, before you decide that your noble intentions justify a lie, ask yourself: “If the person I lie to finds out the truth, will he or she thank me for caring or feel betrayed?” In other words, is the lie likely to damage trust?

Here are some other guidelines:


  • Be sure the benefit you’re trying to gain by lying is important enough to risk a loss of trust.

  • Don’t lie if you can accomplish your noble goal without lying (remember, necessity is not a fact, it’s an interpretation).

  • Be careful that the lie doesn’t cause serious unintended consequence (e.g., telling a child that a monster will take him or her away could generate serious long-term anxiety).

This is Michael Josephson reminding you that character counts.

 What do you think of this commentary?


Comments

I think the people who disagreed with this commentary are likely to be absolutists who believe that lying is always wrong or that it is hypocritical to lie to your children while teaching them to tell the truth.

People who work for our country lie to protect us - they're called spies.

Sometimes people lie to protect the feelings of others if telling the truth would serve no purpose other than to upset someone.

However, children don't have the judgment to determine when lying might be appropriate in a given situation. Therefore, we have to teach them not to lie.

As they mature, they will learn when to make an exception.

One thing I haven't heard mentioned is using the art of redirection rather than lying. My grandmother was a master of this and I do my best. She said it is not okay to lie (with the exception of extreme circumstances like spies), but it is okay to change the subject. Most of us don't have a genuinely compelling reason to lie.

For instance, when a woman you love asks you if she looks good in a dress that makes her look terrible, tell her she looks beautiful but the dress doesn't flatter her. If you can, tell her the red dress she had on the other day did more to enhance her beauty.

If a child asks what happens to her pet when he dies, say you don't know exactly. Ask what she thinks and listen to her answer attentively. Then tell her that wherever he is you're sure her pet will always love her and that love can comfort her when she's sad. Encourage her to honor her pet by remembering the good times they shared.

If someone gives you a present you hate and they ask you how you like it, beam your gratitude at them and tell them how thoughtful and generous it was of the person to think of you, and say you don't have anything like it, thank you.

There are wonderfully creative ways to avoid lying in everyday life if you look for them.

I think telling the truth is very important because you are learning how to be honest. Telling the truth keeps you from getting out of trouble and if you never lie people will always believe you. Telling the truth every time is not always good because you may hurt someone's feelings when you say you stink or something like that so you should only say the right thing. Instead of saying, "Oh, I have it already," you should just say a normal thank you to the person. THIS IS MIGUEL SAYING THAT CHARACTER COUNTS AND THANK YOU EVERYBODY.

If your mom or dad lies to you, then they will say that a little lie never hurt anyone, but when the kid tells a lie, the parent says that it's not good to lie. So I think telling a lie is sometimes okay, but you need to know how to use it. For example: If your friend asks you "Am I too fat for cheerieading?" and you say "No," then when your friend goes to tryout and the head cheerleader says she's too fat, then your friend can't trust you anymore. So then parents should lie to their kid because the kid would not know when to make a good lie from a bad lie. So you parents out there need to teach your kids when to lie and when not to.

Many grown-ups lie but for one reason. To make other people happy. Many grown-ups have kids right and when their son or daughter is scared, sad, worried, or mad they tell a little fib to make them happy. One example is when Michael Josephson posted "Parenting by Lying." That is one good example that parents lie. Not also parents lie. Kids under the age 18 tell a lot of lies just to not get a lot of trouble. So parents lie but also kids lie.

When I was a child, I grew up trusting my mom no matter what. I never remember thinking for even a second that she was not telling me the absolute truth. Looking back, I think this was the basic foundation for a very healthy relationship with my mom that we still have today. She still tried to protect me as a parent should but never used any lies in doing so. I remember her telling me a few times that "sometimes the truth hurts, but it's the truth." I guess in a way she did lie to me about Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny. However, she did tell me later on that she never lied to me. She just let society and marketing do their magic and the rest fell into place. She pointed out when I was in third grade that she was merely going along with what I told her, not me going along with what she told me.
As an adult and mother myself, sometimes I call her for advice on things such as discussing where babies come from. She says always tell the truth. Even if it is uncomfortable for you, just spare the details and most children are happy with a very simple answer. Well, my oldest son is now in Jr. High and he has just told me he knows I will give him a truthful answer because I have never lied to him. So trust is important. It kept me out of a lot of trouble as a teenager and so far has worked wonderfully for my children.

Post a comment

(To guard against spam, we review all comments before posting them. Thank you for your patience.)

Stay connected

Subscribe to the weekly Commentary newsletter.
You can easily unsubscribe, and we will never share your email address.

subscribe to Michael Josephson's podcast in iTunes  iTunes podcast
  RSS  Atom Add to My Yahoo!

Browse by subject

Products

CHARACTER COUNTS! products and materials

All proceeds benefit the nonprofit Josephson Institute.

Archives

Radio

Stations around the U.S. air these commentaries. See where and when to tune in »

Print Media

Commentaries appear in these publications:

Ask your local paper to carry them!

Contact, Donate

Josephson Institute is a nonprofit organization working to create a world where people act more ethically. We need your help to provide free services like the Commentary. Please consider making a tax-deductible donation online. To reach us or to send a check, click here.

CharacterCounts.org  |  JosephsonInstitute.org


LISTEN ONLINE

Translate this page


©2010 Josephson Institute. All rights reserved.
about | store | seminars | work for us | contact us | 800-711-2670
"CHARACTER COUNTS!" is a registered trademark of Josephson Institute. The Institute's Centers: