Michael Josephson Commentary
Josephson Institute  >  Commentary  >  The Cookie Thief 626.3

The Cookie Thief 626.3

There’s a nice poem by Valerie Cox circulating on the Internet about a woman who bought some cookies and a book at an airport and sat down to read and nibble while waiting for her plane. She soon noticed a man sitting next to her, who casually took a cookie from the bag.

Although shocked and seething, the woman remained silent as the man, without the slightest sign of shame or gratitude, quietly helped himself, matching her cookie for cookie.

When there was one cookie left, she watched in amazement as he picked it up, smiled at her as if he were being gracious, and broke it in half. He ate one half and gave her the other. Congratulating herself for maintaining her cool, she said nothing to this rude cookie thief, astonished at the nerve of some people.

Later, when she was settling into her seat on the plane, she rummaged through her purse and discovered the bag of cookies she’d purchased, still unopened. The moral message is contained in the poem’s closing stanza:

“If mine are here,” she moaned with despair,
“Then the others were his, and he tried to share.”
Too late to apologize, she realized with grief,
That she was the rude one, the ingrate, the thief.*

Being sure is not the same as being right. Certainty without humility can lead to self-righteousness that distorts our view and understanding of the world and of people.

Humility doesn’t require us to be equivocal or doubtful about our deepest convictions. What it asks is that we hold and advocate our beliefs without dismissing the possibility that others may be right instead.

This is Michael Josephson reminding you that character counts.

*To read the full poem by Valerie Cox, go to: http://www.motivatingquotes.com/cookie.htm

 What do you think of this commentary?


Comments

This is such a perfect fable for these turbulent times. I showed this commentary to my boss – a die-hard Republican – and his first comment was, “Sounds just like the Democrats.” I then showed it to a coworker – a die-hard Democrat – and he said, “Sounds just like the Republicans.” The problem isn’t the Republicans or Democrats, it’s the fact that they both spend so much time blaming each other that they don’t have any time left to find out what the real problems and solutions are. Shakespeare had it wrong: “The first thing we do, let's kill all the politicians." Figuratively, of course. : )

They could have communicated right from the get-go and avoided getting shocked and angered, and he would have shared his cookies in a more comfortable fashion.

I'm sorry, but parables have to make sense. She just bought cookies and a book. The book was in her hand but the cookies were in her purse -- why? Apparently, she remembered opening the bag of cookies and setting it down next to her. She either did not notice the man sitting there with his bag next to him or he came along after she sat down and she only decided to reach for a cookie from the bag she thought was hers after he sat down. Frankly, the point this makes is that there seems to be something wrong with this woman. She can't keep track of something she just bought, imagines she has done something she has not (opened the bag of cookies and set it down next to her), is oblivious to her surroundings (another person and their bag of cookies), etc.

Awesome story! I wonder what the gentleman was thinking while she was eating his cookies.

Post a comment

(To guard against spam, we review all comments before posting them. Thank you for your patience.)

Stay connected

Subscribe to the weekly Commentary newsletter.
You can easily unsubscribe, and we will never share your email address.

subscribe to Michael Josephson's podcast in iTunes  iTunes podcast
  RSS  Atom Add to My Yahoo!

Browse by subject

Products

CHARACTER COUNTS! products and materials

All proceeds benefit the nonprofit Josephson Institute.

Archives

Radio

Stations around the U.S. air these commentaries. See where and when to tune in »

Print Media

Commentaries appear in these publications:

Ask your local paper to carry them!

Contact, Donate

Josephson Institute is a nonprofit organization working to create a world where people act more ethically. We need your help to provide free services like the Commentary. Please consider making a tax-deductible donation online. To reach us or to send a check, click here.

CharacterCounts.org  |  JosephsonInstitute.org


LISTEN ONLINE

Translate this page


©2010 Josephson Institute. All rights reserved.
about | store | seminars | work for us | contact us | 800-711-2670
"CHARACTER COUNTS!" is a registered trademark of Josephson Institute. The Institute's Centers: