Michael Josephson Commentary
Josephson Institute  >  Commentary  >  The Age of Accountability 545.2

The Age of Accountability 545.2

Religious traditions and legal systems throughout the world agree that young children can’t be held guilty of sins or crimes because they don’t understand the moral consequences of their actions.

The age of accountability varies among religions and cultures. The Catholic Church puts the age at eight, when a child can participate in the sacrament of confession. In Judaism, boys at 13 and girls at 12 can become a bar or bat mitzvah and be held morally responsible for their actions.

In the Anglo-American legal system, a person must normally be 14 to be held criminally liable. In some traditional Latin-American cultures, a girl becomes an adult at 15.

In America, most children look at various age benchmarks in terms or rights or privileges -- they can drive at 16, smoke, vote, and serve in the military at 18, and drink alcohol at 21.

Religious “coming of age” traditions are more concerned with obligations and responsibilities.

Last week, my 12-year-old daughter Abrielle, in a solemn but joyous ceremony, formally left her childhood to accept the responsibilities of an adult. The essence of the bat mitzvah process, involving reading from the Torah, is accepting the moral duties prescribed by Jewish law. The Hebrew bat mitzvah means “one to whom the Commandments apply.”

Of course, moral duties are distinct from legal ones. As a former Justice of the Supreme Court said, “There’s a big difference between what you have a right to do and what is right to do.”

At a conference for lawyers, an attorney declared, “My job is to keep our clients out of jail.” When my turn came, I said, “My job is to keep them out of hell.”

This is Michael Josephson reminding you that character counts.

Comments

Thank you for thinking of others and for writing about behavior that inspires others to be seeking things that are noble, praiseworthy, honest, loving and trustworthy.
I applaud what you are doing with the Josephson Institute.

I am 55 yr old woman now.When I was between the ages of 5-9 my brother was 11-15 he raped me, also he would sell me to my cousins and they would also.Does this make them accountable.My brother says he was too young to know better.

Hi, why is it when a boy dates a girl, the girl says she is 18 years old and lies about it, the boy goes to jail and is branded for life. Please explain this to me. I have never heard of such a nonsence in my life. What about the girl?

Thank you so much for your hard work and committment to the future of our world.
I admire your tough love and tenderness

Post a comment

(To guard against spam, we review all comments before posting them. Thank you for your patience.)

Browse by Subject



Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe to receive the commentaries each Thursday.
You can unsubscribe at any time, and we will never share your e-mail address.

Products

Featuring Michael Josephson ...
What Will Matter (CD with slideshow, PowerPoint, screensaver)
The Best Is Yet to Come (hardcover book)
Making Your Character Count (double audio CD)
Poem Posters (set of four)

Flip through the virtual catalog
or call (800) 711-2670.

All proceeds benefit the nonprofit Josephson Institute.


©2008 Josephson Institute. All rights reserved.
about | store | seminars | work for us | contact us | 800-711-2670